Loop 01 · Soil

Feed the Soil, Not the Plant

Bagged fertiliser feeds this year's crop and leaves the ground poorer. Compost and mulch feed the life in the soil, and that life feeds every crop after. This is the loop everything else hangs on.

Hands lifting a mound of dark, finished compost from a heap in shadow

The Soil Loop at a Glance

The loop in one line

If it grew here, it can rot here

Peelings, spent crops, weeds without seed heads, grass, leaves, cardboard and coffee grounds all go back on the plot. What comes out of the bin in autumn is what goes on the beds in winter. You stop buying compost and start making it.

Build a heap
Method

Cool heap

Add as you go, leave it a year. Easy, forgiving, but weed seeds survive.

Method

Hot heap

Build a cubic metre in one go, turn it, and it can reach 55–65°C, which kills most weed seeds.

Why soil comes first

Healthy soil is a sponge, a larder and a workforce in one. Organic matter holds water through dry spells, releases nutrients slowly as microbes break it down, and gives worms, fungi and bacteria something to eat. Feed that system and it feeds your plants. Skip it and you're stuck buying fertiliser, watering more and fighting compaction every spring.

The closed-loop version is simple: nothing organic leaves the garden in a council bin if it can rot on site. Sir Albert Howard laid this out in An Agricultural Testament in 1940, based on the layered Indore method he developed in India. Eighty-odd years later, it still works on a back garden.

Build a heap that works

Most failed heaps are either too wet and slimy or too dry and dead. Aim for roughly equal volumes of "greens" (fresh, wet, nitrogen-rich: peelings, grass, green weeds) and "browns" (dry, carbon-rich: cardboard, straw, autumn leaves, shredded stems). Garden Organic gives the same rule of thumb.

  • Size: at least a cubic metre if you want heat. Smaller bins still compost, just slowly.
  • Moisture: like a wrung-out sponge. Too wet, add cardboard. Too dry, add greens or water.
  • Air: turn it once or twice, or poke holes with a fork. Smell means it's airless.
  • Two bays: one filling, one finishing. Three if you have the space.

Leave out cooked meat, fish and dairy in an open heap; they draw rats. Perennial weed roots like bindweed and couch grass can drown first in a lidded bucket of water for a few weeks, then go on the heap as sludge.

No dig, less work

Charles Dowding has run side-by-side dig and no-dig beds at Homeacres in Somerset for years, and the no-dig beds hold their own or better on yield with far less weeding. The method: lay cardboard over grass or weeds, cover with 10–15 cm of compost, plant straight in. Each year, top up with 3–5 cm. Digging breaks the fungal threads that move water and nutrients, and it lifts buried weed seed into the light. Don't do it unless you have to.

Go peat-free

Peat bogs store vast amounts of carbon and take thousands of years to form. Digging them up for seed trays makes no sense. For sowing, use sieved leaf mould mixed with sieved garden compost. For potting on, buy a peat-free mix; the RHS has trialled them and the better brands now perform well. Water peat-free mixes little and often at first, because the surface can look dry while the middle stays wet.

Mulch, compared

Mulch is a lid on the soil. It cuts evaporation, suppresses weeds and feeds the soil life as it breaks down. Match the mulch to the job:

Common garden mulches
MulchBest forBreaks downFeeds soilWatch out
Garden compostVeg beds, no-dig3–6 monthsHighWeed seeds if the heap stayed cool
Leaf mouldWoodland plants, seed mixes6–12 monthsModerate, great structureTakes 1–2 years to make
Wood chipPaths, fruit trees, shrubs1–3 yearsLow at first, builds fungiKeep off seedlings; don't dig it in
StrawStrawberries, squash, potatoes6–12 monthsLowCheck it's free of aminopyralid herbicide
CardboardClearing grass and weeds2–4 monthsLowRemove tape and glossy print
Grass clippingsThin layers round cropsWeeksModerate, nitrogen-richThick layers go slimy; never from treated lawns

Seasonal tasks

  • Top up beds with 3–5 cm of compost before planting.
  • Turn the heap once the weather warms; start a fresh bay.
  • Dig in nothing. Rake the surface fine for direct sowing.
  • Mulch after a good rain, never onto dry soil.
  • Keep the heap damp; summer heaps dry out fast.
  • Compost spent crops straight away; chop them small.
  • Collect leaves into wire cages or punctured bags.
  • Sow green manure such as field beans or winter rye on empty beds.
  • Empty finished compost and spread it before the ground gets wet.
  • Lid or cover the heap against waterlogging.
  • Keep off wet soil; use boards if you must walk on beds.
  • Plan next year's beds around how much compost you'll have.