Grower FAQ

Straight Answers for Growers

The questions we get over the allotment fence, answered without hedging. If yours isn't here, ask us.

Getting started

Do I need a big garden to garden sustainably?

No. A balcony with a worm bin, one water butt or a few buckets of rain, and a pot of saved lettuce seed is a closed-loop garden. Scale doesn't matter; direction does.

Soil

Is no-dig really less work?

After the first season, yes. Setting up needs cardboard and a lot of compost, but afterwards you only top up 3 to 5 cm a year, and weeding drops because buried weed seed stays buried. See no dig.

Soil

Why does my compost heap smell or go slimy?

It's too wet and short of air, usually from too many greens such as grass clippings. Mix in torn cardboard, straw or dry leaves and turn it with a fork.

Water

Is it safe to use rainwater on vegetables?

For watering the soil around fruit and vegetables, yes. Keep butts lidded, clean them yearly and water the roots rather than leaves you'll eat raw. Use mains water for seedlings if your butt water is old and murky.

Seed

Can I save seed from supermarket vegetables?

Sometimes. Many are F1 hybrids that won't grow true, and some are imported varieties unsuited to your climate. Dried beans and some heritage tomatoes can work, but saving from your own open-pollinated plants is more reliable.

Seed

What's the difference between F1 and open-pollinated seed?

F1 seed comes from crossing two parent lines; plants are uniform but their seed won't breed true. Open-pollinated seed breeds true if kept from crossing, so you can save it year after year.

Pests

Are slug pellets ever okay?

Metaldehyde pellets have been banned for outdoor use in Great Britain since 31 March 2022. Ferric phosphate pellets are permitted but are a last resort. Raising seedlings bigger before planting, night patrols and predator habitat work better long term.

Pests

How do I get rid of aphids without spraying?

Squash early colonies, knock them off with a jet of water, and wait a week or two. Ladybirds, hoverflies and lacewings follow the aphids if you have flowers and shelter nearby.

Soil

Is peat-free compost any good?

The better brands now perform well in RHS trials. Water little and often at first because the surface dries faster than the core. For sowing, sieved leaf mould mixed with garden compost works well and is free.

Natives

Do I have to plant only natives?

No. Your vegetables aren't native either. Aim for a solid backbone of native hedging, trees and wildflowers alongside crops and well-chosen non-natives that flower for a long season.