A pest is just food that hasn't been found yet. Spray it and you kill the things that eat it too, then the pest comes back faster than its hunters. Build a home for the hunters instead.
The Predator Loop at a Glance
The loop in one line
Pests feed predators, predators protect crops
Aphids are lunch for ladybird and hoverfly larvae. Slugs are dinner for frogs, beetles, thrushes and hedgehogs. Keep a few pests around, give the predators water, shelter and flowers, and the balance looks after itself after a season or two.
No fish, a shallow sloping edge, and frogs and toads will find it within a year.
Method
Leave the mess
Log piles, long grass edges and standing hollow stems shelter overwintering beetles and ladybirds.
Why sprays break the loop
Rachel Carson made the argument in Silent Spring in 1962 and it still holds: broad-spectrum pesticides don't discriminate. They kill aphids and the ladybirds eating them, slugs and the beetles hunting them. Pests breed fast and bounce back within days; their predators breed slowly and take far longer. Every spray makes the next outbreak worse. Dave Goulson's Silent Earth sets out how much insect life has already been lost and why gardens, together, are a serious refuge. Pesticide Action Network UK campaigns for pesticide-free towns and has plenty on going chemical-free at home.
Meet the workforce
Ladybirds: adults and especially larvae eat aphids by the hundred.
Hoverflies: adults pollinate; their legless larvae are aphid specialists.
Lacewings: larvae eat aphids, mites and small caterpillars.
Ground beetles and rove beetles: night hunters of slugs, slug eggs and root fly larvae.
Frogs, toads and slow-worms: slug control with a cold-blooded patience.
Song thrushes, blue tits and hedgehogs: snails, caterpillars and grubs.
Parasitic wasps: tiny, harmless to you, and deadly to caterpillars and aphids.
Build them somewhere to live
Predators need the same things you do: water, food, shelter and a place to raise young. A small pond without fish is the single most effective addition. A log pile in a shady corner houses beetles and toads. Leave hollow perennial stems standing through winter; cut them back in spring, not autumn. Plant for a long flowering season, from early pussy willow and crocus to late ivy, with plenty of open, flat flowers such as fennel, dill, calendula, phacelia and yarrow that small predatory insects can feed from. Buglife's B-Lines project maps how gardens can join up into corridors.
Tolerate, then protect
Some damage is the price of balance. A few nibbled leaves are fine; a stripped row is not. Between the two, use barriers rather than poisons:
Fine mesh over brassicas keeps cabbage white butterflies off.
Fleece or 60 cm barriers around carrots stop carrot fly.
Raise slug-prone seedlings indoors until they're big enough to survive a nibble.
Go out with a torch on damp evenings and pick off slugs by hand.
Metaldehyde slug pellets have been banned for outdoor use in Great Britain since 31 March 2022 because of the harm they do to wildlife. Ferric phosphate pellets are permitted, but even those are a last resort in a garden that's trying to feed its frogs.
When things go wrong
New plots and recently sprayed gardens take a season or two to rebalance. Expect an aphid spike in late spring before predators catch up. Squash early colonies with your fingers, knock them off with a jet of water, and accept that a sacrificial nasturtium covered in blackfly is doing its job by keeping them off your beans.
Seasonal tasks
Cut old stems now, after insects have emerged.
Net brassicas before butterflies arrive.
Check for frogspawn; keep pond edges shallow.
Hold your nerve on aphids for two weeks.
Keep flowers going for hoverflies.
Top up ponds with butt water, not tap water.
Build a log pile and leave leaf litter under hedges.
Don't tidy borders; stems are winter quarters.
Plant spring bulbs for early pollinators.
Check bonfire piles for hedgehogs before lighting, or better, compost instead.